How we appraise

A worked example: six units, West London

Every deal we present is built on the same appraisal discipline. Here is that process applied to a hypothetical West London scheme, so you can see how we arrive at a number — and how the fee calculation works.

Illustrative example. A full residual appraisal and sensitivity analysis are included in the deal pack for development and commercial-to-residential projects.

The brief

Assume a portfolio builder is looking for a West London commercial-to-residential scheme, targeting a minimum 25% return on cost, with capital in place and a twelve-month horizon.

The site

Assume a tired retail unit with vacant upper floors on a W3 side street, with poor frontage and a dated layout. The concept is six flats and a modest rear extension, subject to planning, design and technical checks. No planning entitlement is assumed to be confirmed.

Gross Development Value — £2,390,000
Unit mixUnitsValue eachTotal
1-bedroom4£360,000£1,440,000
2-bedroom2£475,000£950,000
GDV6£2,390,000
Total Development Cost — £1,925,950
Line itemAssumed basisCost
Land / purchase priceAssumed price£680,000
Acquisition costsAllowance for SDLT, legals, survey and due diligence£45,000
Build costs5,000 sq ft GIA at £185/sq ft£925,000
Professional fees10% of build£92,500
Kestrel sourcing fee4% of the £680,000 purchase price; includes reservation fee£27,200
Contingency5% of build£46,250
Finance costsAllowance for a 12-month senior debt term£110,000
Total Development Cost, including Kestrel’s fee£1,925,950
Profit after development costs, including Kestrel’s fee£464,050
Profit on cost, including Kestrel’s fee24.1%
Profit on GDV, including Kestrel’s fee19.4%

What our fee would be

Kestrel’s £27,200 sourcing fee is included in the development cost table above, alongside professional fees and the other scheme costs. The profit figures shown above are calculated after deducting it.

Finder’s fee: £27,200

The £1,000 non-refundable reservation fee forms part of that fee, leaving £26,200 payable on exchange for a private investor, or on completion for a corporate investor, under the sourcing agreement.

How the returns are calculated: £2,390,000 GDV − £1,925,950 total development cost = £464,050 profit. Profit on cost is £464,050 ÷ £1,925,950 = 24.1%. Profit on GDV is £464,050 ÷ £2,390,000 = 19.4%.

The illustrated return falls below the brief’s 25% target and would need to be addressed before proceeding.

Fee assumption for this illustration: the 4% rate is based on the 25.9% return on cost before the sourcing fee. The returns reported above include the fee. The ROI definition and fee basis are agreed in writing before sourcing; this example does not set those terms for your deal.

This simplified illustration is not a complete investment appraisal. Selling costs and any additional tax or VAT treatment are not modelled; these would need to be established and included where applicable. Values, costs, finance, timing and planning are assumptions, not independently verified evidence for this example.

How we would evidence a live appraisal

  • Sold comparables — completed sales of equivalent units within a defined radius, adjusted for size, floor and condition.
  • Build costs — rates benchmarked against current local tender returns, with the specification and scope made clear.
  • Conservative assumptions — values at the lower end of the supported range and costs tested against downside scenarios.
  • Contingency held, not spent — an allowance retained against the unknowns that conversions can produce, sized to the actual scheme’s risk.

Every figure that sets our fee is evidenced in the deal pack before you commit.

Understand the numbers

Deal calculators

Seven practical tools to assess a property opportunity, understand the costs and test your assumptions. Free to use, with no sign-up required.

01 / FREE CALCULATOR

Stamp Duty Calculator

Estimate Stamp Duty Land Tax for a purchase in England or Northern Ireland, with residential, commercial and mixed-use options.

Open calculator
02 / FREE CALCULATOR

Rental Yield Calculator

Calculate gross and net operating yield, then see the cash flow after your mortgage and running costs.

Open calculator
03 / FREE CALCULATOR

BMV Calculator

Compare the purchase price with an evidenced market value, include the full costs, and assess the potential margin.

Open calculator
04 / FREE CALCULATOR

Deal Analyser

Model buy-to-let, Flip, BRR, HMO and serviced accommodation strategies with visible costs and adjustable assumptions.

Open calculator
05 / FREE CALCULATOR

Residual Development Appraisal

Estimate the supported land or site price from GDV, development costs, finance and your target developer return.

Open calculator
06 / FREE CALCULATOR

Commercial-to-Residential Analyser

Screen a conversion, build a detailed John Howard-style cost appraisal, and compare sale with refinance-and-hold outcomes.

Open calculator
07 / FREE CALCULATOR

Rent-to-Rent Calculator

Model serviced accommodation or room letting, calculate annual ROI and see how occupancy affects cash flow and break-even.

Open calculator

Find a deal that fits your numbers.

Tell us your investment criteria. We source and appraise opportunities against your agreed brief.

Join Our Investor Network